Moderators: Immortals, Supreme Beings, Old Ones
WuTang Mushroom wrote:Maybe a terribly easy answer to all of these questions
Delta Green
or
Rocks Fall
and a quick question:
Can a magic user cast Astral hole whilst he is subject to a bottomless pit spell?
cornholioprime wrote:If you launch a Palladium Books/Rifts™ Vampire (in a sealed, lightproof coffin with soil of the homeland in it, of course) into orbit around the sun, would it sleep forever WITHOUT going hungry and insane??
Elthbert wrote:cornholioprime wrote:If you launch a Palladium Books/Rifts™ Vampire (in a sealed, lightproof coffin with soil of the homeland in it, of course) into orbit around the sun, would it sleep forever WITHOUT going hungry and insane??
No, vampires don't need to sleep in space at all. There is no "daylight" in space. In order for there to be "daylight" you need an atmosphere to defuse the light. Vampires are scary as hell in space. But i would agree that there should be some sort of limit to how long they could go without food, even with the mystical link between day and night and feeding, there should be a limit.
Dog_O_War wrote:Elthbert wrote:cornholioprime wrote:If you launch a Palladium Books/Rifts™ Vampire (in a sealed, lightproof coffin with soil of the homeland in it, of course) into orbit around the sun, would it sleep forever WITHOUT going hungry and insane??
No, vampires don't need to sleep in space at all. There is no "daylight" in space. In order for there to be "daylight" you need an atmosphere to defuse the light. Vampires are scary as hell in space. But i would agree that there should be some sort of limit to how long they could go without food, even with the mystical link between day and night and feeding, there should be a limit.
Given that vampires are affected by Sunlight, I disagree.
This situation also renders unshadowed space very much like an ocean, in the traditional vampire sense.
Agreed on most points, and following along those same lines I assume that to a Vampire on Pluto, the Sun might be nothing more than "just" another star, and he could stay awake there indefinitely (which reminds me of an old Sci-Fi short story in which a supervillain finds a way to turn himself, and eventually ends up on Neptune or Pluto in an eternal state of bottomless hunger, spending the rest of his eternal days lusting for death by sunlight).Qev wrote:That's an interesting question, now that I think about it. "Day" really is just a function of the Earth, and not of the Sun. So from that point of view, it makes perfect sense that vampires in space wouldn't need to sleep, as there is no such thing as "Day" or "Night" when you're away from a planet's surface.
It's not unreasonable to consider it "continual daytime" in space, though, in which case vampires are screwed. You could say that vampires can only operate in the shadows of natural bodies that are spherical due to their own gravity (ie. planets, moons, really big asteroids), which is a fairly general description of the "Day/Night" phenomenon, and even works for tidally locked bodies. Maybe there's something magical about natural spheres; circles are kind of the antithesis of the rectilinear cross-shape, and are well-known in magic.
You'd have to define some sort of threshold where sunlight becomes weak enough that it counts as general nighttime, otherwise you run into the starlight problem. I'd just apply the inverse-square law to the damage, and make the cut-off the point where sunlight does less than a maximum of 1/2 HP per melee (which would be a little ways past Saturn's orbits). This would lead to a really creepy situation of vampires lurking in the dark gulfs between stars, preying on unsuspecting outer system and interstellar travel.
That said, it must really suck to be a vampire on a planet in a binary star system.
Sarael wrote:Damian Magecraft wrote:cute...
but somehow i think not...
I already resolved this conundrum...
Iwas just curious what others think...
The silver rune is a specific rune, which renders it and the page indestructible. The ink magically disappears from a scroll though, it's not destroyed, it's magically removed to cast the spell from it.
Qev wrote:That's an interesting question, now that I think about it. "Day" really is just a function of the Earth, and not of the Sun. So from that point of view, it makes perfect sense that vampires in space wouldn't need to sleep, as there is no such thing as "Day" or "Night" when you're away from a planet's surface.
It's not unreasonable to consider it "continual daytime" in space, though, in which case vampires are screwed. You could say that vampires can only operate in the shadows of natural bodies that are spherical due to their own gravity (ie. planets, moons, really big asteroids), which is a fairly general description of the "Day/Night" phenomenon, and even works for tidally locked bodies. Maybe there's something magical about natural spheres; circles are kind of the antithesis of the rectilinear cross-shape, and are well-known in magic.
You'd have to define some sort of threshold where sunlight becomes weak enough that it counts as general nighttime, otherwise you run into the starlight problem. I'd just apply the inverse-square law to the damage, and make the cut-off the point where sunlight does less than a maximum of 1/2 HP per melee (which would be a little ways past Saturn's orbits). This would lead to a really creepy situation of vampires lurking in the dark gulfs between stars, preying on unsuspecting outer system and interstellar travel.
That said, it must really suck to be a vampire on a planet in a binary star system.
Elthbert wrote:Dog_O_War wrote:Given that vampires are affected by Sunlight, I disagree.
Sunlight can be interpreted in two ways. Either it means the light generated by a star after it hits an atmosphere and defuses into the all encompassing daylight. Or it means the light of Sun/Sol anywhere, which means that Vampires are not endangered anywhere in the megaverse other than in the Solar System ie. our star system. It cannot be any other, because starlight does not hurt them. In space Sun's light is no differant than any other star's, So unless they fear starlight, that cannot be a viable interpretation. For that matter the light of the moon is Sunlight and vampires do not fear it. Therefore it must be a mystical effect tied to the light of DAY, not based on starlight from Sun/Sol or not.
Dog_O_War wrote:Elthbert wrote:Dog_O_War wrote:Given that vampires are affected by Sunlight, I disagree.
Sunlight can be interpreted in two ways. Either it means the light generated by a star after it hits an atmosphere and defuses into the all encompassing daylight. Or it means the light of Sun/Sol anywhere, which means that Vampires are not endangered anywhere in the megaverse other than in the Solar System ie. our star system. It cannot be any other, because starlight does not hurt them. In space Sun's light is no differant than any other star's, So unless they fear starlight, that cannot be a viable interpretation. For that matter the light of the moon is Sunlight and vampires do not fear it. Therefore it must be a mystical effect tied to the light of DAY, not based on starlight from Sun/Sol or not.
That's foolish. Also, FIREBALL! Because you're applying real-world science to an element of fantasy.
Vampires were invented when people had many misconceptions about the Earth, the Sun, and space itself. That said, it's been traditionally "Sunlight". Since our star is the only one we call "the Sun", I really don't see how this could be confusing.
Besides this, vampires have a great many things to fear in space - no food, for example. No respite from our Sun for as long as there are no intervening objects. Being frozen solid. Beheading. Drifting aimlessly because they lack a means of propulsion. Space-Vampire-Slayers.
Elthbert wrote:Do you allow people to use UV lights to hit a vampire and hurt them? Or does it have to be actual sunlight? If it has to be actual sunlight then it is not a scientific reaction but a mystical one. It is for this reason that I contend it is only sunlight in an atmosphere, outside of an atmosphere it is starlight, the sun does not "light up" space like it does the Earth. I simply see no reason why they would be effected in space at all. While you might argue that it is always day in spae you could just as easily argue it is always night. In fact, I think the idea that it is always night has more merit, precisely because space is not lit inthe same way as an atmosphere bearing body is.
). It could be something as simple as that a planet is massive enough to block the magical emanations of its sun, whereas a less substantial barrier won't. Could be an interesting plot hook to discover a group of vampires trying to engineer a work-around to this problem, scientifically or magitechnically. Qev wrote:Elthbert wrote:Do you allow people to use UV lights to hit a vampire and hurt them? Or does it have to be actual sunlight? If it has to be actual sunlight then it is not a scientific reaction but a mystical one. It is for this reason that I contend it is only sunlight in an atmosphere, outside of an atmosphere it is starlight, the sun does not "light up" space like it does the Earth. I simply see no reason why they would be effected in space at all. While you might argue that it is always day in spae you could just as easily argue it is always night. In fact, I think the idea that it is always night has more merit, precisely because space is not lit inthe same way as an atmosphere bearing body is.
I generally go the "direct sunlight or daylight of sufficient intensity" route, myself, and besides, it's a magical effect, so UV lights and lasers and suchlike are out. Moonlight wouldn't hurt vampires under my setup, either, since it falls below the brightness threshold by a decent margin, and well... it's moonlight.
I guess we're just coming at it from different philosophical viewpoints. Yours is that the atmosphere is what makes sunlight special, and mine is that night is special because it doesn't exist without planets (or a great deal of distance
One problem I could see with space always being considered night is... well... there wouldn't be any other space-faring civilizations, because they'd all have been promptly overrun by the vast ravening hordes of sunlight-unfettered space vampires.
Elthbert wrote:Qev wrote:That's an interesting question, now that I think about it. "Day" really is just a function of the Earth, and not of the Sun. So from that point of view, it makes perfect sense that vampires in space wouldn't need to sleep, as there is no such thing as "Day" or "Night" when you're away from a planet's surface.
It's not unreasonable to consider it "continual daytime" in space, though, in which case vampires are screwed. You could say that vampires can only operate in the shadows of natural bodies that are spherical due to their own gravity (ie. planets, moons, really big asteroids), which is a fairly general description of the "Day/Night" phenomenon, and even works for tidally locked bodies. Maybe there's something magical about natural spheres; circles are kind of the antithesis of the rectilinear cross-shape, and are well-known in magic.
You'd have to define some sort of threshold where sunlight becomes weak enough that it counts as general nighttime, otherwise you run into the starlight problem. I'd just apply the inverse-square law to the damage, and make the cut-off the point where sunlight does less than a maximum of 1/2 HP per melee (which would be a little ways past Saturn's orbits). This would lead to a really creepy situation of vampires lurking in the dark gulfs between stars, preying on unsuspecting outer system and interstellar travel.
That said, it must really suck to be a vampire on a planet in a binary star system.
Elthbert wrote:All of that said I have had Vampires rip through the hull of a ship in a star system in my game as the party was searching planets for a particular signal. The look on my players faces was priceless.
cornholioprime wrote:The Palladium Vampire's vulnerability to Sunlight is mystical, not physical; he is therefore vulnerable to the rays of the Sun wherever he encounters them (and is vulnerable to the light of the Sun on other worlds, too, not just Sol).
In one of the Phase World supplemental Books, there is a HLS that involves a Vampire on a planetary colony on an airless world; the Players have to figure out how to defeat a Vampire on a world where the sun never rises and the creature and his minions never have to sleep (due to its constantly being in an orbit that always keeps it in the larger world's shadow).
We can therefore assume from the HLS put forth by the authors that Vampires don't need a starlight-diffusing atmosphere in order to suffer from the various effects of the Sun.
Qev wrote:I could see a really dark variation on the Phase World setting, where all the 'civilized' races huddle around the warm light of bright stars, the only thing holding back the monsters lurking in the interstellar dark. Monsters that constantly try to sneak ships full of sleeping infiltrators into the dark sides of their worlds and moons. Interstellar travel would be desperate, risky dashes between the tiny pools of light that are their only safety.
Mark Hall wrote:This setting is called "Fading Suns"
), or does it get expelled from the circle, or does it just not work? That always seemed to me as if that thing just acted as a simple Barrier to them; to me, it would both keep the Demon in and keep other Demons out.Qev wrote:Mark Hall wrote:This setting is called "Fading Suns"
Sweet, I'm going to have to find a copy of this.
Here's a silly question: if you have a Circle of Protection from (let's say) Demons, and there's a demon inside the circle when it's closed, is the demon then protected from demons (:lol:), or does it get expelled from the circle, or does it just not work?
cornholioprime wrote:I am, or rather was, a Tattooed Maxi-Man.
At some point in my life I, deciding to live as long as humanly possible, go Full Conversion 'Borg -as in, the kind where my brains and guts are all that remain of me.
After a long, long, long, long life of adventures as a 'Borg, I stumble across Rifts Japan, hook up with Ichto or the New Republic or whoever it is that gives out that illegal Cloning Treatment on the side, and have them use the DNA in my remaining body parts to clone me a brand-new body and place my brain back into it.
Do my Magic Tattoos eventually come back the same way that they would if I "only" lost a tattooed Arm or Leg and had them replaced with real flesh??
All Floopers all the time wrote:What happens if you dump a whole lot of water on a Burster's flame aura? Like say, 1 cubic metre (1,000 kg) of water?
cornholioprime wrote:Psionic Energy is one of the few forms of Energy that can cause injury to a vampire -more or less the same as Wood and Silver.
If my Psi-Sword stabs a Vampire in the heart, will it be paralyzed/sent into stasis, or are the 'paralyzing' substances limited ONLY to Wood or Silver in the heart??
cornholioprime wrote:Psionic Energy is one of the few forms of Energy that can cause injury to a vampire -more or less the same as Wood and Silver.
If my Psi-Sword stabs a Vampire in the heart, will it be paralyzed/sent into stasis, or are the 'paralyzing' substances limited ONLY to Wood or Silver in the heart??
csbioborg wrote:if you get enough rune weapons together can you destroy them by creating a black hole?
Tee Hee......which would NEVER evaporate.Qev wrote:csbioborg wrote:if you get enough rune weapons together can you destroy them by creating a black hole?
Being canonically indestructible, I doubt you could actually destroy them in this fashion. You could still make a black hole out of them, rendering them inaccessible, though... and creating the galaxy's first RUNE BLACK HOLE.
cornholioprime wrote:Tee Hee......which would NEVER evaporate.Qev wrote:csbioborg wrote:if you get enough rune weapons together can you destroy them by creating a black hole?
Being canonically indestructible, I doubt you could actually destroy them in this fashion. You could still make a black hole out of them, rendering them inaccessible, though... and creating the galaxy's first RUNE BLACK HOLE.
cornholioprime wrote:Tee Hee......which would NEVER evaporate.Qev wrote:Being canonically indestructible, I doubt you could actually destroy them in this fashion. You could still make a black hole out of them, rendering them inaccessible, though... and creating the galaxy's first RUNE BLACK HOLE.
csbioborg wrote:so would they collapse on itself or would the blackhole be the size of the original rune weapons?
The reason why it's potentially "hard" is that, in other instances, if you lose your real arm and have it replaced with cybernetics or bio-systems, you lose some of your mystic powers supposedly because (IIRC) the saying went something along the lines of the PPE being linked to the body as a whole.Balabanto wrote:Yes. That's not really that hard. If the ability is granted to you by your class, then you get to keep it. If the ability is granted to you by your Race, and you are cloned, then you are still that race. So I really don't think that one's particularly complicated.
I'm going to first look up what their 'class abilities' are before I answer that one.Here's one for you.
If your Battle Magus becomes an MDC creature, do they lose all of their class abilities?
cornholioprime wrote:I am either an Apok or a Sea Inquisitor (pick your choice).
At some point in my existence, the Republic of Japan Docs get me a biological clone body and place my brain into it.
Does my ability to cause Double Damage to the Supernatural/Supernatural Evil follow me into this new body??
cornholioprime wrote:The reason why it's potentially "hard" is that, in other instances, if you lose your real arm and have it replaced with cybernetics or bio-systems, you lose some of your mystic powers supposedly because (IIRC) the saying went something along the lines of the PPE being linked to the body as a whole.Balabanto wrote:Yes. That's not really that hard. If the ability is granted to you by your class, then you get to keep it. If the ability is granted to you by your Race, and you are cloned, then you are still that race. So I really don't think that one's particularly complicated.
Therefore, the question becomes 'what happens if almost ALL of the new body that you now live in isn't your original one??
Qev wrote:csbioborg wrote:if you get enough rune weapons together can you destroy them by creating a black hole?
Being canonically indestructible, I doubt you could actually destroy them in this fashion. You could still make a black hole out of them, rendering them inaccessible, though... and creating the galaxy's first RUNE BLACK HOLE.
cornholioprime wrote:My opponent stands before me. greatly weakened, within a Anti-Magic Cloud.
I have no other means to get at him or effectively damage him (he's MDC), and my going into that cloud as a fellow Mage will put me at a distinct disadvantage due to the fact that he will still be able to function (he too is a Mage, and he cast the Cloud).
In a burst of 'insight,' I expend the necessary PPE energy to cast "Annihilation" and throw it into the Cloud (at the enemy mage); the description of the Spell states that the secondary spell affects cover an area of damage sufficient to catch the enemy mage within it (provided, of course, that I throw the Sphere in manner that allows it to be close enough to the enemy Mage before it makes contact with the Cloud).
The description of "Annihilate" also states that it is big ol' blob of antimatter, contained by Magic Forces.
If I throw the Sphere into the Cloud, does it go off 'normally' by dint of the Cloud prematurely canceling out the containment magic, or does the whole Sphere -summoned antimatter and all -disappear before it impacts with something solid, and without causing any damage???
Elthbert wrote:Sunlight can be interpreted in two ways. Either it means the light generated by a star after it hits an atmosphere and defuses into the all encompassing daylight. Or it means the light of Sun/Sol anywhere, which means that Vampires are not endangered anywhere in the megaverse other than in the Solar System ie. our star system. It cannot be any other, because starlight does not hurt them. In space Sun's light is no differant than any other star's, So unless they fear starlight, that cannot be a viable interpretation. For that matter the light of the moon is Sunlight and vampires do not fear it. Therefore it must be a mystical effect tied to the light of DAY, not based on starlight from Sun/Sol or not.
cornholioprime wrote:Why can't a Mega-Juicer, constantly infused with and soaked with Psionic Energy from his head down to his toes (for those of you who don't know, they even explode in a massive, MDC explosion of Psionic Energy for their Last Call)......be able to damage True Supernatural Creatures with his bare hands the way that Psionic Energy does??
For that matter, Dogs can inflict damage to the supernatural under certain conditions**, so why can't Dog-Boys, who are genetically 100% dogs themselves??
**No, really. I forget which book it's in, but animals of various types can affect the supernatural -for example, the crow of a Rooster can temporarily disable some monsters. The blurb about Dogs is also in that section, but for the life of me I can't remember which Book it's in right now.
Rune Weapons are NOT changed in alignment by absorbing more souls; it is implied very strongly that only the soul(s) present at the weapon's creation determine "who" the weapon will be -not any subsequent ones.Reaper wrote:If you are a hero of light with a soul draining rune weapon, you slay evil and drain their souls into the blade, stronger and stronger souls, would the soul in the weapon, a good alignment soul, be over shadowed and the weapon become an evil one? Then would the weapon try to envoke its will upon the hero?
cornholioprime wrote:Rune Weapons are NOT changed in alignment by absorbing more souls; it is implied very strongly that only the soul(s) present at the weapon's creation determine "who" the weapon will be -not any subsequent ones.Reaper wrote:If you are a hero of light with a soul draining rune weapon, you slay evil and drain their souls into the blade, stronger and stronger souls, would the soul in the weapon, a good alignment soul, be over shadowed and the weapon become an evil one? Then would the weapon try to envoke its will upon the hero?
It is not 100% clear whether or not those souls are totally, utterly destroyed, or if they are somehow sent on their way to the Afterlife -in neither event, though, are they added to the Rune Weapon's 'inventory,' and by no means does the weapon ever exchange one soul -or personality -for another.
Sureshot wrote:Listen you young whippersnappers in my day we had to walk for 15 no 30 miles to the nearest game barefoot both ways. We had real books not PDFS and we carried them on carts we pulled ourselves that we built by hand. We had Thaco and we were happy. If we needed dice we carved ours out of wood. Petrified wood just because we could.
Greyaxe wrote:cornholioprime wrote:Rune Weapons are NOT changed in alignment by absorbing more souls; it is implied very strongly that only the soul(s) present at the weapon's creation determine "who" the weapon will be -not any subsequent ones.Reaper wrote:If you are a hero of light with a soul draining rune weapon, you slay evil and drain their souls into the blade, stronger and stronger souls, would the soul in the weapon, a good alignment soul, be over shadowed and the weapon become an evil one? Then would the weapon try to envoke its will upon the hero?
It is not 100% clear whether or not those souls are totally, utterly destroyed, or if they are somehow sent on their way to the Afterlife -in neither event, though, are they added to the Rune Weapon's 'inventory,' and by no means does the weapon ever exchange one soul -or personality -for another.
It is very unlikley that you would have a goodly alligned "soul Drinker" Which in my opinion is an inheriently evil property of a weapon.
Subjugator wrote:Elthbert wrote:Sunlight can be interpreted in two ways. Either it means the light generated by a star after it hits an atmosphere and defuses into the all encompassing daylight. Or it means the light of Sun/Sol anywhere, which means that Vampires are not endangered anywhere in the megaverse other than in the Solar System ie. our star system. It cannot be any other, because starlight does not hurt them. In space Sun's light is no differant than any other star's, So unless they fear starlight, that cannot be a viable interpretation. For that matter the light of the moon is Sunlight and vampires do not fear it. Therefore it must be a mystical effect tied to the light of DAY, not based on starlight from Sun/Sol or not.
As vamps are vulnerable to sunlight in other spheres and on other planets, it is not restricted to terra. With that said, the light from the moon is reflected - that could cause it to lose effect. I say that direct (not reflected, et al) contact with the light of a sun is what matters.
/Sub
There are TONS of them; just look in Pantheons of the Megaverse for a start.Elthbert wrote:Greyaxe wrote:cornholioprime wrote:Rune Weapons are NOT changed in alignment by absorbing more souls; it is implied very strongly that only the soul(s) present at the weapon's creation determine "who" the weapon will be -not any subsequent ones.Reaper wrote:If you are a hero of light with a soul draining rune weapon, you slay evil and drain their souls into the blade, stronger and stronger souls, would the soul in the weapon, a good alignment soul, be over shadowed and the weapon become an evil one? Then would the weapon try to envoke its will upon the hero?
It is not 100% clear whether or not those souls are totally, utterly destroyed, or if they are somehow sent on their way to the Afterlife -in neither event, though, are they added to the Rune Weapon's 'inventory,' and by no means does the weapon ever exchange one soul -or personality -for another.
It is very unlikley that you would have a goodly alligned "soul Drinker" Which in my opinion is an inheriently evil property of a weapon.
You said it before I could. A good aligned weapon would not be soul eater. I still stuggle with the idea htat there are good aligned rune weapons at all.
In my campaign holy weapons while using rune magic, do not have an entity trapped within them and regular rune weapons are only good under the strangest of circumstances.
cornholioprime wrote:So while Rune Weapon Creation is an undeniably evil act 99.9999999% of the time (yes there are a few examples of people who wanted to put themselves into a Rune Weapon), the act of Soul Drinking is no more or less 'evil' to an enemy than killing them in combat.
The Beast wrote:cornholioprime wrote:So while Rune Weapon Creation is an undeniably evil act 99.9999999% of the time (yes there are a few examples of people who wanted to put themselves into a Rune Weapon), the act of Soul Drinking is no more or less 'evil' to an enemy than killing them in combat.
I did a quick check and none of the soul drinkers I found were from a good alignment, so they may be correct on this.
Sureshot wrote:Listen you young whippersnappers in my day we had to walk for 15 no 30 miles to the nearest game barefoot both ways. We had real books not PDFS and we carried them on carts we pulled ourselves that we built by hand. We had Thaco and we were happy. If we needed dice we carved ours out of wood. Petrified wood just because we could.
csbioborg wrote:cornholioprime wrote:Why can't a Mega-Juicer, constantly infused with and soaked with Psionic Energy from his head down to his toes (for those of you who don't know, they even explode in a massive, MDC explosion of Psionic Energy for their Last Call)......be able to damage True Supernatural Creatures with his bare hands the way that Psionic Energy does??
For that matter, Dogs can inflict damage to the supernatural under certain conditions**, so why can't Dog-Boys, who are genetically 100% dogs themselves??
**No, really. I forget which book it's in, but animals of various types can affect the supernatural -for example, the crow of a Rooster can temporarily disable some monsters. The blurb about Dogs is also in that section, but for the life of me I can't remember which Book it's in right now.
isn't that in Chaos Earth?
Balabanto wrote:Well, something called The Devastator should Devastate things. 1d6x10 couldn't devastate your mother in Rifts.
amodernheathen wrote:If, in one posting, I can increase the hellish chaos of even a single planet seven-fold, then I believe that I have done my duty as a Game Master to the widows and orphans of that world. By increasing their number. Drastically.
cornholioprime wrote:There are TONS of them; just look in Pantheons of the Megaverse for a start.Elthbert wrote:Greyaxe wrote:cornholioprime wrote:Rune Weapons are NOT changed in alignment by absorbing more souls; it is implied very strongly that only the soul(s) present at the weapon's creation determine "who" the weapon will be -not any subsequent ones.Reaper wrote:If you are a hero of light with a soul draining rune weapon, you slay evil and drain their souls into the blade, stronger and stronger souls, would the soul in the weapon, a good alignment soul, be over shadowed and the weapon become an evil one? Then would the weapon try to envoke its will upon the hero?
It is not 100% clear whether or not those souls are totally, utterly destroyed, or if they are somehow sent on their way to the Afterlife -in neither event, though, are they added to the Rune Weapon's 'inventory,' and by no means does the weapon ever exchange one soul -or personality -for another.
It is very unlikley that you would have a goodly alligned "soul Drinker" Which in my opinion is an inheriently evil property of a weapon.
You said it before I could. A good aligned weapon would not be soul eater. I still stuggle with the idea htat there are good aligned rune weapons at all.
In my campaign holy weapons while using rune magic, do not have an entity trapped within them and regular rune weapons are only good under the strangest of circumstances.
Remember, Soul Drinking doesn't also imprison other souls within itself when it drinks them, it either utterly destroys them or sends them on their way. Either way nobody else gets imprisoned within the weapon itself.
So while Rune Weapon Creation is an undeniably evil act 99.9999999% of the time (yes there are a few examples of people who wanted to put themselves into a Rune Weapon), the act of Soul Drinking is no more or less 'evil' to an enemy than killing them in combat.
