Arcanum and Tome Grotesque for Beyond the Supernatural

Trent · Unread post by **Trent** » Sun Jul 26, 2015 2:52 am

taalismn wrote:
Trent wrote:[
There is so much you can do with BTS .

Yes. But it requires more thinking, planning, and discretion. Unless you've set the campaign in a warzone, you can't just say "we go and buy some tactical nukes and start blowing up stuff" with the same abandon you might have in other game settings.

Well some people like games that make you think . Not everyone wants hack n slash or shoot em ups .

taalismn · Unread post by **taalismn** » Sun Jul 26, 2015 7:41 pm

Trent wrote:[Well some people like games that make you think . Not everyone wants hack n slash or shoot em ups .

Hence my argument/agreement that BTS books and adventures take a lot more thought and preparation, and why writing up new sourcebooks isn't as simple as 'let's toss in a GAZILLION new weapons and monsters!'.

Trent · Unread post by **Trent** » Sat Aug 01, 2015 1:54 am

taalismn wrote:
Trent wrote:[Well some people like games that make you think . Not everyone wants hack n slash or shoot em ups .

Hence my argument/agreement that BTS books and adventures take a lot more thought and preparation, and why writing up new sourcebooks isn't as simple as 'let's toss in a GAZILLION new weapons and monsters!'.

Yes I get that but its just that the two books were promised as being in production and coming soon when the core book was first advertised . That's been many years ago and many other source books have came out for other games instead . Many only bought the core book thinking the two others to complete the game were very soon to follow . Had they know otherwise they may not have spent the money on that first book .

nakorn66 · Unread post by **nakorn66** » Sun Aug 16, 2015 1:07 pm

I hope they are released soon

- a fan from Thailand

gaby · Unread post by **gaby** » Mon Sep 21, 2015 8:20 am

Well I hoping Palladium books can fouce on Beyond the Supernatural in 2016?

They did the Dead regin books,Why is BtS so Hard for them?

What do you think is ther problem in making BtS,s books?

The Beast · Unread post by **The Beast** » Mon Sep 21, 2015 9:53 pm

gaby wrote:What do you think is ther problem in making BtS,s books?

Not enough people buy them.

Daniel Stoker · Mon Sep 21, 2015 9:58 pm

Well not having a complete game makes it kinda a self fulfilled prophecy there where people don't buy a book to a game they can't play.

Daniel Stoker

GreenGhost · Unread post by **GreenGhost** » Thu Sep 24, 2015 8:55 pm

I've ran a BTS game since the original first came out. It's been the longest running game that my players and I have done. When the new BTS was released, I bought it too. What I've done for years is create paranormal creatures for the party to investigate and hunt. Even though I've done this for years and actually like doing it this way, but I've got to admit, it would save me a lot of time if I had the Tome of the Grotesque in hand.

pblackcrow · Unread post by **pblackcrow** » Thu Oct 08, 2015 2:57 am

The Beast wrote:
gaby wrote:What do you think is ther problem in making BtS,s books?

Not enough people buy them.

Wrong, last time I checked, first edition is selling well in e-book. Mind you, this was like a year ago; so. The problem is 2nd edition. The changes Kevin made to 2nd Ed were not well received with my players. And I still do not like playing or GMing straight 2nd ed. I mean, yeah characters needed a BIT of spicing up and a few tweaks made here and there. The PPE of the mage/arcanist increased and some new spells and psychic abilities, added. But I was a bit disappointed with the absurdity of the rules for ISP. Still my groups play a combination of first and second editions. With the understanding that absolutely none of the characters get the bonus ISP from the monsters. House ruled and completely rejected that notion in all of the groups that I have played in and GMed. And also, I am not allowed to play an autistic psychic again...LOL. LONG AND FUNNY STORY! But one for another day, as it's going on 3:00am.

But I do want to say that I am not trying to be negative or condescending. If I come off that way, I am sorry. But please don't think that I am. I like Palladium games and am a major fan of BtS. And most likely always will be. My dislikes are quite easily fixable with a quick reset to the original system and a few tweaks here and there all is well.

Valadus2001 · Unread post by **Valadus2001** » Sat Nov 07, 2015 6:11 pm

I'm tired of waiting for them. If it's true that they BtS is dead then my interest in palladium has pretty much died as well.

Holister · Unread post by **Holister** » Sun Nov 08, 2015 8:53 pm

Ok, reality is, they BTS 2nd edition came out in 2005, that wa slike like 10 years ago. They have no intention of ever EVER putting out those other bboks. Buying a BTS 2nd edition is a waste of time and money. They spent all their time and effort on Dead Reign because "zombie apocalypse" is the big "In" thing that is popular. If you like BTS, just find yourself a copy of 1st edition, at least that was a complete game in and of itself (psychic abilities, magic, and monsters all in oone book, plus a few campaign ideas in the back), plus their there are alot of book you can use with it including BOXED NIGHTMARES the sourcebook for BTS 1st edition, monsters & animals (1st edition more so than 2nd in my opinion), and Mystic China are alsovery compatible.

Well that was my 2 cents... Game On!

Eric42 · Unread post by **Eric42** » Sat Nov 14, 2015 7:04 pm

Note: The recent update is saying three sourcebooks are PLANNED for 2016. I know that means little, but who knows?

Holister · Unread post by **Holister** » Sun Nov 15, 2015 12:28 am

Dude, don't hold your breath. Pal promises alot and delivers a little.

MurderCityDisciple · Thu Feb 11, 2016 8:53 pm

Two words...BTS KICKSTARTER!!

The Beast · Unread post by **The Beast** » Thu Feb 18, 2016 8:44 pm

MurderCityDisciple wrote:Two words...BTS KICKSTARTER!!

Yeah, that's gonna do well... :roll:

MurderCityDisciple · Fri Feb 26, 2016 6:38 am

Hey last weekly update said BTS stuff is coming out this year....yay!!!

Can't wait...

Jasper · Unread post by **Jasper** » Fri Feb 26, 2016 11:37 pm

Yaay, the same vague mention of upcoming BTS stuff in the weekly update!

Looking forward to it too!

eliakon · Unread post by **eliakon** » Sat Feb 27, 2016 4:31 am

The Beast wrote:
MurderCityDisciple wrote:Two words...BTS KICKSTARTER!!

Yeah, that's gonna do well...

Dunno Lemuria and both Northern Gun books were crowd sourced if I recall.
And unlike the RTT issue there are no third parties involved. Collect the money needed to pay people to write the book.
I would be willing to kick in the twenty bucks for a Kickstarted book. Yeah I know its a gamble....but its a gamble I would be willing to take since the pay off (getting a BTS book) is rather large.

Vrykolas2k · Unread post by **Vrykolas2k** » Wed Apr 13, 2016 6:25 pm

I thought they'd been released and I just hadn't seen them on the shelves yet.
Geez...
Anyway, I guess with a little tweeking you can just use the stats from Palladium Fantasy for everything in BTS...

Jasper · Unread post by **Jasper** » Wed Apr 13, 2016 9:20 pm

Vrykolas2k wrote:I thought they'd been released and I just hadn't seen them on the shelves yet.
Geez...
Anyway, I guess with a little tweeking you can just use the stats from Palladium Fantasy for everything in BTS...

True...kind of. I don't know too much about Palladium Fantasy magic but BTS magic, if it works like the psychic rules, can't be cast openly. It'll likely have an escalating power source depending on the level of supernatural threat nearby. That's an assumption though. Another possibility is that while psychics are powered that way maybe arcanists (BTS casters) are powered differently, ie. Cults, rituals etc. That's always been the big appeal of BTS magic to me. Fantasy casters are kind of like superheroes with powers whereas BTS is much more subtle. But we don't know for sure what Kevin intends as the rules aren't out yet...

tmikesecrist3 · Sat Sep 03, 2016 8:46 am

I would like to see this befor the end of the year my self but I am not holding my breath..... it is sad we dont already have this in our hands

MidnightBlue · Unread post by **MidnightBlue** » Sat Oct 01, 2016 5:46 pm

There are no possible titles that I've seen listed or hinted at that I want more than the completion of the long promised BTS 2E books.

I still happily have my BTS 1E and Boxed Nightmares books and they are prized jewels among two and a half, long, bookcase shelves of Palladium Books RPGs.

Can't wait to see what they do with magic and finally get some more monsters to take on in 2E.

Jasper · Unread post by **Jasper** » Sun Oct 02, 2016 1:59 pm

MidnightBlue wrote:There are no possible titles that I've seen listed or hinted at that I want more than the completion of the long promised BTS 2E books.

I still happily have my BTS 1E and Boxed Nightmares books and they are prized jewels among two and a half, long, bookcase shelves of Palladium Books RPGs.

Can't wait to see what they do with magic and finally get some more monsters to take on in 2E.

I"m the same. I have shelves of Palladium stuff but the only things I want (need) are the magic and monsters books for BTS 2e.

Prons · Unread post by **Prons** » Mon Nov 07, 2016 3:16 am

There's still a month left in the year. #RIP

cesuhr · Unread post by **cesuhr** » Tue Nov 29, 2016 1:13 pm

yeah always promised but still have not delivered. I am about to give up on seeing these books in the near future. the promise has been broken.

Hunterrose · Unread post by **Hunterrose** » Fri Dec 23, 2016 3:57 pm

I'd love to see some BtS supplements. But for my part, I'm currently setting up a HU Campaign and I'm happy combining and mixing different games together. Luckily I have 2 psychics and a Ghost as PCs so they fit well in the BtS world. But I'm also using stuff from Pal Fantasy, Gumshoe, TMNT, Rifts, and Dark Champions.

Once I have source material, I'm not finding it too difficult to create NPC Stats in the HU Mold.

For example there's a 5th level Fire Manipulating Mutant in one of the stories I'm adapting. I love the story but this guy's stats are useless to me. But I know what he needs to do in the narrative and I know how to make Fire Guy Powers in HU so problem solved.

Wintercross · Unread post by **Wintercross** » Sat Dec 31, 2016 5:54 am

I would like to see these source books get done, managed to pick up some Palladium books and currently working on prep work for a BTS campaign via Roll20.

A lot of holes I need to patch in though.

Vrykolas2k · Unread post by **Vrykolas2k** » Tue Feb 28, 2017 10:13 pm

Eric42 wrote:Note: The recent update is saying three sourcebooks are PLANNED for 2016. I know that means little, but who knows?

Some of us remember when Mechanoid Space was planned for 1995...

gaby · Unread post by **gaby** » Tue Jun 06, 2017 7:51 pm

I love it,that info on Arcanum and Tome Grotesque is coming in Rifter.

Holister · Unread post by **Holister** » Wed Jun 07, 2017 1:20 am

It would be better if they just put out the books like they were supposed to ... 12 YEARS AGO.

gaby · Unread post by **gaby** » Sat Jun 24, 2017 6:37 pm

You Known I am staring to Hate Dead Reign,they are Close too book 8 and Beyond the Supernatural is only One!
What is Up with That?
You can doo so much more with BtS.

I will Stay strong and Keep Hope alive.

Holister · Unread post by **Holister** » Sat Jun 24, 2017 8:13 pm

I agree. BtS is a horror based RPG that has such a wide range of possibilities and can be combined with several other books to further expand on that without affecting the basis of the game. like Boxed Nightmares, Nightbane, and Mystic China. Even sourcebooks like Systems Failure, Monsters & Animals, Hades, & Dyval can be used to add to it if you want to go that route.

Dead Reign, on the other hand, is a fad, that's it. Zombie survival, once Walking Dead gets canceled, will lose its momentum and phase out. Dead Reign should have been a sourcebook for BtS at best and left at that. I feel as though Palladium should have put more of an effort into BtS or least guide things into that direction, especially since they have had the two remaining CORE books "coming soon" for over 12 years now. I also have hope that one day they will get their act together and deliver what was promised. In the meantime, I refer to BtS 1st edition and add to it as I see fit. There are also so many game books out there that are based in the supernatural its insane provided you know where to look.

Not for nothing, and no offense to Palladium, but horror is more than zombies and vampires. If you really enjoy good horror based RPGs like me, you might want to check out our Facebook group. It's more than just BtS, but you might like it. Here is the link. In the meantime, Gaby don't lose hope and keep the faith.

https://www.facebook.com/groups/BlackRabbitGames/?ref=group_cover

gaby · Unread post by **gaby** » Sun Jun 25, 2017 7:51 pm

I will.

I say Tome Grotesque part 1 will be made first,It will be a Mix of Updated Monsters from 1st ed and All New Ones.
What Monsters from 1st ed do you hope they will keep?

I Hope they make the Monsters from Rifter canon,ther very good.

Holister · Unread post by **Holister** » Mon Jun 26, 2017 12:27 am

I would like to see them keep the usual suspects like werewolves, vampires, zombies, ghosts, & mummies, but I want to see them keep the mindolar, narcarant, dybbuk, and boschala. As for new additions maybe the imp, succubus, and golem.

gaby · Unread post by **gaby** » Fri Jun 30, 2017 7:30 am

Well Arcanum will have all the Magic info from 1st ed,puls some New Info,the Updated Arcanist,Other Magic Occ.
I hope they will have some Magic items.

Holister · Unread post by **Holister** » Fri Jun 30, 2017 2:50 pm

I would like to see a druid class (a shout out to Kon Thaak from back in the day), a priest class (modern priest; I've done it so I know it's possible), a witch class (both white/light and dark/evil witch), and maybe a modern mystic and/or a magician class.

Eddie Focus · Unread post by **Eddie Focus** » Thu Jul 27, 2017 8:12 pm

Still waiting ... hoping ... someday ...

gaby · Unread post by **gaby** » Sat Jul 29, 2017 6:54 am

We must always keep hoping.

If they Stop Dead regin they can focus on BtS?

gaby · Unread post by **gaby** » Tue Aug 01, 2017 10:17 am

How will they set up the Spells and not make the copy of Palladium fantasy?

What Spells do you want to see in BtS?

Jasper · Unread post by **Jasper** » Wed Aug 02, 2017 12:01 am

gaby wrote:How will they set up the Spells and not make the copy of Palladium fantasy?

What Spells do you want to see in BtS?

Great question. A while ago I started a short document that I called "BTS Wishlist" containing the things I liked from 1rst edition and things that I would like to see changed, as well as themes and other things etc. It's a question deserving of its own topic - perhaps called "Arcanum and Tome Grotesque Wishlist". I'd start it myself but really, my list isn't that long, I need to keep it open and add things as they occur to me.

But I will say this - 1rst edition was pretty great except when it came to Arcanists. With that one class you could pretty much do anything a psychic could do if you had the spells - telekinesis, pyrokinesis, astral travel, healing, clairvoyance, various types of detecting etc. Why have a psychic at all? Arcanists could even borrow PPE from others to fuel themselves (a great idea actually, in ritual settings or with trained channellers as assistants) but it was yet another leg up on psychics.

if Arcanum ever does come out I would like to see a variety of magic types so that one class can't do "everything" (am I exaggerating? That's the way I remember it). Or perhaps the type of caster you are doesn't matter but you have to select a certain "path" to go down and that limits your choices from thereon and maybe even restricts other things. Just some thoughts.

neftosis · Unread post by **neftosis** » Sun Oct 25, 2020 2:47 am

Eddie Focus wrote:Still waiting ... hoping ... someday ...

Three Years later - GUYS! Seriously... I've been waiting like half my life for these books!!
Can we help?
Can we do a kickstarter?!?!!?!?! anyone!?!?

BTS and NaSS are both such good settings and more love should be sent their way

gaby · Unread post by **gaby** » Sun Oct 25, 2020 8:08 am

Yes,your Right!

Please Palladium books do BtS,s Books in the Next Year.

mrloucifer · Unread post by **mrloucifer** » Sun Oct 25, 2020 12:37 pm

They're not forgotten. Kevin and I were talking recently about how the magic in BTS will work. Things are moving slowly but they are moving. I will help speed up the process as much as I can.

In the meantime I may write something about how the magic will work so players can incorporating aspects in their game with BTS1 arcanist rules in the meantime.

Rogerd · Unread post by **Rogerd** » Sun May 16, 2021 4:58 pm

The trouble with this product is that it is like Cinematic Unisystem: Beyond Human. Promised for release over ten, may be twelve years. While some would buy it even now, most have moved on from that system due to lack of support and wouldn't bother buying even if released. It is just too late. We just do not care.

The same is true here.

So for PB to announce that the product is moving slowly, the last post being eight months old, coupled with the fact that 15 years to produce a book is beyond taking liberties with the loyal base here. It is in essence producing vapourware. I personally would not buy it now and can substitute the BtS magic feel with other products.

Palladium Books needs to get its act together.

gaby · Unread post by **gaby** » Wed Jul 21, 2021 10:38 am

I hope they put NB:TtGD and Rifter 27,s Sorcerous Proficiencies and Limiations,Spcialy Limitions in a low Magic BtS,s World,ther can be inherent from How the Character learn Magic (thier school of magic),the Source ther of Magic power or a Curse.
They can always wokr on Overcoming it.

What do you think?

Jasper · Unread post by **Jasper** » Wed Jul 21, 2021 12:37 pm

gaby wrote:I hope they put NB:TtGD and Rifter 27,s Sorcerous Proficiencies and Limiations,Spcialy Limitions in a low Magic BtS,s World,ther can be inherent from How the Character learn Magic (thier school of magic),the Source ther of Magic power or a Curse.
They can always wokr on Overcoming it.

What do you think?

That's funny, I was literally reading the sorcerous proficiencies page yesterday but haven't gone through them all yet. I don't like the "immunity to magic" one because it makes no sense for a spellcaster. That aside, I definitely do want to see some variation for spell-casting, including a number of different classes so that it's not just one class that gets all the spells like before. Some further variation with choosable (or rollable) proficiencies, powers sources, etc would be pretty neat. I really like the Channeler class from TgGD - they fill the role in a modern setting of cult leaders, priests, etc (in addition to other things) as they haven't learned their magic, rather it's granted to them, albeit in a different way than Pact Witches who make a deal of service.
I also like the idea of differentiating oral tradition spellcasters - people like traditional witches (as opposed to Pact Witches), Druids, "Voodoo" style casters, from more standard book-learning Arcanists and Sorcerers.
I like the idea of of Parapsychologists being able to cast spells from books and scrolls in ritual forms but with no "off-hand" casting.
I like the Acolyte from TgGD, but I don't like the fact that they have psychic powers, it doesn't fit with BtS (in my mind). Instead, they would provide PPE for their leader and be able to cast like the Parapsychologist.
I like the Mystic having both psychic powers and innate spells.
Some off-hand thoughts.

mrloucifer · Unread post by **mrloucifer** » Wed Jul 21, 2021 1:55 pm

gaby wrote:I hope they put NB:TtGD and Rifter 27,s Sorcerous Proficiencies and Limiations,Spcialy Limitions in a low Magic BtS,s World,ther can be inherent from How the Character learn Magic (thier school of magic),the Source ther of Magic power or a Curse. They can always wokr on Overcoming it. What do you think?

I've not read this article before (that I can recall, but I get hit in the head a lot), but now that I have I think its got a lot of potential and variety to offer. I've since added it to my "Magic User Template for BTS-2" I've been working on in the House of BTS Discord page.

Jasper wrote:I like the Acolyte from TgGD, but I don't like the fact that they have psychic powers, it doesn't fit with BtS (in my mind). Instead, they would provide PPE for their leader and be able to cast like the Parapsychologist.

I agree and it is puzzling that the option to provide PPE wasn't blatantly offered. That said, the Acolyte does not have to take any psionics; they can be psionic free. On the other hand, I think there is a "Restore PPE" psionic ability they could take to do this very thing. Also, as they gain ISP regardless, I think there's a "Convert to P.P.E." spell in one of the books the cult leader could use to gain PPE from the acolyte as well. Still, if I get a chance to add the acolyte to Beyond Arcanum, I would include this as part of the package.

barna10 · Unread post by **barna10** » Sun Sep 25, 2022 10:29 pm

And....still nothing