Colonel_Tetsuya wrote:More precisely:
Such "cards" already exist. You think a General doesn't carry an ID saying he's a General? That shows you what security clearance he has?
I assure you, he does. Same exact result. He comes in and tells you to do something, you do it.
Everyone in the CS Military carries some kind of ID card showing their clearance and rank, be it an actual card, or built into their armor, or (more likely) a simple sub-dermal implant.
As for the Black Market knocking them off:
1 - they have to know they exist.
2 - they have to know who has them
3 - they then have to get one from said people, without them knowing (because if they know you got one, they simply change all the codes immediately).
4 - they then have to be able to copy the card completely and have it work. Given that its entirely possible to create encryption that can take literal centuries to break, this isn't a given.
5 - as these are Psi-Bat operatives (or a division thereof), the cards could be Psi-tech and tied to the owners' Psionic Profile. It will only work for them and in their presence. And thats just one example of security that could be applied.
I find the entire argument of "ID Cards that let you do whatever you want are a giant security hole!!11!!1@2:"21!" to be a complete farce.
They already exist.
bull crap.
if a general that is your direct commander shows up, you take their orders. if some other random general shows up at your base, unannounced, they'd better be able to convince you to do what they want, because being a general gives you specific people that you command, it doesn't just make you the boss of every person in the army with a lower rank than you. now, if a general asks for something pretty small (borrow a vehicle and driver to get them to a place they're supposed to be, for example), you'll probably do it because it's low cost, low risk to lend a hand, and potentially a high cost to your career if you prove to be a total jerk to them. depending on how suspicious a base commander feels, some random unknown general showing up at their base with no notice that they're supposed to be there may be detained (somewhat politely, but still detained), especially when the military is paranoid from constantly being warned against shapeshifting wizards and demons and someone can literally just steal the general's body and try to walk into your base while wearing them like a halloween costume.
even if you're pretty sure they're the real deal, if they show up and inform you that they're taking 3/4 of your men to search for a bad guy, well, good luck with that. they may be *a* general, but unless they're *your* general, i don't see it happening. a command structure where any person can command any person of lower rank would be absolute chaos. they'd be the laughingstock of the village militia of podunksville (population 200 peasants armed with pointy wooden sticks and the contents of grany hill's silverware drawer to share between the lot of them), never mind an actual professional military force.
if a general is going to show up and take command of your unit, it is not going to be in the form of showing up at your base with a card and informing you that you now work for that general. most of the time, you'll know at least somewhat in advance, there'll be a ton of paperwork involved, and proper channels will be used to spread that information to those that need to know it. there are things a military might want to hide. who your direct superior is would not be one of those things.
anyways, to the specific points:
1) everyone already does. they have to, otherwise you're not requisitioning the right to use their toilet, let alone commandeering troops and/or supplies, access to records, interrogating (or even seeing) their prisoners, etc.
2) again, everyone already does. this cannot be hidden information. people have to know who they have to obey. if that is "anyone who has a card, no matter what responsibilities they may or may not have" then everything is going to go straight to hell in short order, and not just because of fake cards; conflicting orders in a war zone is not something any remotely competent military is going to go on for very long.
3) nope. for example, the reader has all the information they need, otherwise it can't tell you whether the card is the real thing. they could also simply record what information is broadcast, get pictures of what the card looks like, etc. the card doesn't have to be real, it just needs to be a good enough fake.
4) there's literally a skill that any random schmuck can take for breaking codes. now you may argue that secure codes *should* be trivial, but for whatever reason, they aren't in palladium games.
5) nothing remotely indicates this to be the case. certainly there is nothing that remotely implies any card reader could detect their psionic presence, so frankly, who cares? all you need is for whatever fake you make to broadcast whatever the widely-available readers that every single military unit in the CS is apparently supposed to have thinks it is supposed to hear. it doesn't matter if it's real or not. it doesn't matter if that broadcast from the real card normally samples your blood and sequences your entire genome before it broadcasts, so long as your fake can be made to do it on demand.