Hey!
Ok, so I'm new here, been playing Palladium since 1986/87 (year or two after Robotech was released).
Just got Splicers, 2 weeks ago, since it got added to RPGnet [Please note "powers-that-be", I will NEVER buy a [standard] physical book again - I LITERALLY have to take a suitcase full of nothing but Palladium books with me every time I want to play a game... Taking my laptop is VASTLY more efficient, love your books, have bought many pdf's and will buy more!!! Please move up your PDF availability PLEASE!!! /end rant]
I love it!!!!!!!! Awesome book, and interesting setting. Aside from anything else, it is EXACTLY kind of "tech" I've always wanted in a PB game - it (literally) grows with you!! No more - "look my [type x armor/bot] is awesome!" at level 1, but at level 7... "Wait, you can do WHAT now? well... crap....."
I just spent several hours reading all the posts, and if I may, I would like to wade in on Therumancer's original postings. I hope I'm not re-opening any old wounds, but I have to admit, in my own reading of the book, I came up with almost the exact same "issues", though I have a very centralized response to them. I warn you this is a very long post, for which I apologize, but he had some serious points, and I tried to give them due consideration and response.
[Bracket numbers are mine]
1. How the bloody heck is anyone in Splicers supposed to be ignorant of what planet they are on? You talk about the machines changing the continents, etc... etc
[1a] Assuming it's a colony world, where the heck is the government that created the colony? Even with nuclear weapons I'd give the machines maybe a year before a coordinated response blew the living crud out of them.
All told when I read this I was sitting here going "What?". I was jokingly thinking of splicers as "The first RPG where it's illegal to look into the sky, or actually use your Astronomy skill".
2. Memory discs and such things aside, I can't see books (which are not metal) being totally destroyed. Again this goes with the whole 'I don't buy this whole premise of ignorance' concept.
4. According to the way how things are written, plastic is not affected by the nano-plague. I don't think this has been thought through very well.
Most electronic devices and stuff are contained inside of plastic. To be quite frank you don't touch much metal using a lot of modern technology.
The way how things are defined, I'm not buying that all technology would pretty much be abandoned. All you'd see is a lot of heavy plastic casing around the stuff that people wanted to use.
[5] Even if that didn't work, electronics would continue to flourish. I mean we've got bio-technology that generated electricity. There is no reason why some bio-technologists couldn't create technology (as opposed to purely living organisms) by making wires out of electricity-generating biological material and then put them inside of a casing. It might be weird to have to feed your computer a steak every once in a while to keep it's electrical components healthy, but it's workable. Plus you could also make a lot of the technology photosynthetic (transparent plastic casing) which wouldn't be much worse than solar-power if it was implemented correctly.
[6] Given records and such I would think that logically people would begin to realize what had went wrong with the AI. Then they could builder faster, sexier, computers (perhaps without AI components) to hack the thing and shut it down.
[7] Not to mention the fact that the whole idea of microscopic robots is a complicated way of doing something that should be simple to do with bio-tech (ie your basically creating a germ). I see no reason why someone doesn't just use uber-bio-technology to create a living anti-body for the nanite plague and release it (ie a microscopic bio-organism that exists for no reason other than to eat the machine's nanites).
[8] This covers a lot of my conceptual problems. My review will eventually touch on a lot of things. To be honest I'm having some trouble getting my head around large portions of the central premise. All science fiction has some kind of holes in it but this one seems to have more than the usual share.
>>>----Therumancer--->
1, 2, 4, 6:
Basically I agree with Therumancer on all these points as "plot holes" or at least "logic holes", but not really his reasoning. If I may explain: all of this could be simple - it's untrue. Not wrong / a misprint in the book, it's just untrue. A conspiracy of the Librarians & Warlords (maybe to fool NEXUS into thinking humans are "falling" faster than she thought? Whatever, there are MANY reasons possible for this).
Unfortunately, why Theru is right is the one GLARING fault in Splicers (PLEASE NOTE, I LOVE these guys, and am planning on using them in other games - this isn't "smack talk" or anything, it's just that they really do "break the 4th wall" in this specific setting).
Technojackers
Yep, imagine this scenario: All of the above questions [1, 2, 4, 6] come up in casual conversation... a technojacker overhears and gets (mildly) curious.... he goes to a ghost town, walks up the first [Public-Library-Of-This-Future-World-From-Their-Past], walks in, touches the first open/unused (preferably out-of-the-way) terminal he comes to, and says "Display basic information on this planet, including name, star name, and any primary slang names."
Absolutely ZERO information (of a non-classified / military nature) could EVER be lost in this world. All one ever need do is hire a TJ for one afternoon, assign them a "normal" partner with a slug modified to record sound and visuals, and BOOM all ignorance is overcome.]
This would include making plastics, at a molecular level - important because even if: Miracle Fiber,
PLASTIC, and Ceramic armors weren't still being made, with this information, the Librarians and Engineers could "cook up" something that would produce such, to be worked with.
As for manufacturing [see above, proving this is still done to some extent anyways], keep the Technojackers away from "normal folk", but make sure they have access to a few Repair wagons [with their comms ripped out], and they have a basic manufacturing plant fully stocked out with everything they need but the supplies.
As for [6], this is again something that sort of blatantly "breaks the 4th wall" - this might not have been doable, even 50 years ago, but given the current state of tech / affairs. This is how you cripple NEXUS (in each given area) in one afternoon:
[Please note this would require YEARS of prep, though only a very few select people would have to know anything about it, until a few days ahead of time.]
• Grow Pods for 50 TJ's [per Computer Core to be attacked, recommend 10 or more depending on troop availability] The Pods grow on the backs of Host Armors, and do nothing but refresh air supply within, and are considered "part" of the host armor [thus no need for the TJ to "access/use" the Bio-Tech],
• add Stealth field,
• stage MAJOR assault on Computer Core,
• now attack 5 "main" entrances with the "special elites" (that you know Ishtar is expecting),
• then have the stealthed HA's walk up to the door, turn around, crack 1 pod, TJ opens door, no alarms, 10 HA's w/TJ's at each door, so if anything bad happens... no prob,
• Walk in, find first terminal, repeat above for directions to "main computer core" at each location. Walk into computer core, dump (and protect) TJ's,
• TJ's initate [TJ-Equivalent-of-DDOS-attack] on NEXUS simultaneously,
• this either: simulates Computer Core shut down (due to overload), trips NEXUS emergency protocols (forcing NEXUS to disconnect), or allows the unified force of TJ's to directly attack the NEXUS core-code..., figure whichever way it goes, effectively or actually shuts down each CC for at least a few minutes, allowing the ENTIRE attacking force to obliterate the Computer Core unopposed.
Granted this would probably only work once, but it would effectively "hand" victory to the humans [for these areas]... and like I said, it would take YEARS of prep... but then, there are probably far more effective/efficient ways of doing this [I don't claim to be a military strategist, or diplomat for that matter]. The problem is that ONE TJ, is effectively impotent against NEXUS, but a few hundred? I doubt NEXUS's defenses ever had anything like a semi-psychic swarm-style assault foreseen. So, again.... those darn TJ's!!!
---
As for [1a] - this one is tricky, Theru might be right OR wrong... since the machine controlled everything, for decades (minimum) it could simply have jammed any emergency calls... though it seems HIGHLY unlikely no one escaped to space since there ARE alien plants/animals, star travel was at some point a reality... On the other hand, Ishtar may have planned for that and waited for a lull in space-traffic, destroyed all ships in the system, and then declared the planet a bio-hazard zone (natural catastrophe? known alien enemy assault? etc...). It may be that the external government had forgotten about them before this, too - maybe the [whatever] planet, had seceded from the space-gov't, and cut off all ties, communications, and travel (for whatever reason)... I agree, it seems unlikely, but it really IS possible that there's no help coming.... [Darker minds might look to an external gov't that is actively watching to see what happens for either political, military, or even just plain ole' scientific curiosity.]
---
[5] I have to agree totally here, between TJ's, Librarians, Engineers, and Geneticists (L/E/G's), there has to be some form of civilian / civilization tech POSSIBLE - however, again, it could be that the above-mentioned conspiracy applies here as well [some form of conspiracy-of-ignorance from the top]. Otherwise this is a gaping plot [logic] hole.
---
Where 7 is concerned, I fully see the "suspension of belief" side... That being said, you would expect by now the L/E/G's would have made either an arm-cuff, or maybe even a skin-suit with the lithovore metabolism, that would act as a symbiotic blood-cleaner, literally eating the nanites from the host, reducing the viral load below the "dangerous" concentration. Also, air-vent "purifiers" to do the same thing to prevent re-infection of the masses... [I take this approach instead of the microbe, because as with all living things, mutation is possible, which could lead to a bigger problem than NEXUS in the end...] Again the easiest answer to this is my oft-mentioned conspiracy of ignorance...
[8] Well, it's been many years since your posting Theru, I've yet to see your full review.. would love to!
------------------------
Please note, this is not / was not meant to be a flame or anything like it. Just my thoughts on some things. I do completely disagree with Theru on one point - I don' think this game is going to die anytime soon, if for no other reason than it's import-ability to other systems.
Also, I must admit (ashamedly) the only reason I didn't buy this book back when it came out was the artwork (I'm sorry, but the cover sucked in my opinion - it didn't capture the description of the game AT ALL, seriously, it looked like standard PA being attacked by a walking 80's boom box). I know, I know.... never judge a book.... lesson learned... (I hope!)
Any comments in response would be more than welcome!