Forums of the Megaverse®

TheWay wrote:What happens if someone casts Anti Magic Cloud in a group of other mages and one of the mages saves then they cast antimagic cloud does that then negate the anti magic cloud cast first. Please elaborate on any other scenarios that could occur as well please

Yes, anti-magic cloud can negate other anti-magic clouds. It really dosn't matter the senario, one anti-magic cloud always negates others so long as something able to cast in an anti-magic cloud casts it, or someone outside of the cloud does.

Nekira Sudacne wrote:

TheWay wrote:What happens if someone casts Anti Magic Cloud in a group of other mages and one of the mages saves then they cast antimagic cloud does that then negate the anti magic cloud cast first. Please elaborate on any other scenarios that could occur as well please

Yes, anti-magic cloud can negate other anti-magic clouds. It really dosn't matter the senario, one anti-magic cloud always negates others so long as something able to cast in an anti-magic cloud casts it, or someone outside of the cloud does.

I would have to disagree...
There is that pesky phrase in the spells description "Cannot be dispelled by magical means"...

IMO: The clouds would co-mingle (covering a larger area) and the original caster would also have to save vs AMC. And assuming both casters make their saves you would then have 2 (or more) mages who are battling it out at 1/2 power. YMMV however.

Anti-magic cloud isn't really a dispelling so much as a surpression of all magic energy in an area.

It made a lot more sense before they gave it a save.

Nekira Sudacne wrote:Anti-magic cloud isn't really a dispelling so much as a surpression of all magic energy in an area.

It made a lot more sense before they gave it a save.

Earliest mention of the AMC spell is in 1st ed Fantasy (Pg. 75) it had a save even then.