Page 1 of 1

MDC by location combat confusion

Posted: Tue Jan 31, 2017 4:26 am
by Delrik
What are the combat rules for dealing with opponents with mdc by location? Are called shots used to target these specific areas?

Re: MDC by location combat confusion

Posted: Sun Feb 05, 2017 9:22 am
by ShadowLogan
Yes you can make called shots to specific locations. It really doesn't matter if you have MDC by location or not, but having it makes it a bit easier to gauge effect of an attack (ex, did I destroy/disable that 'bots leg or not with that shot).

Re: MDC by location combat confusion

Posted: Sun Feb 05, 2017 2:03 pm
by say652
At level 5 and higher, called shots become a viable Combat action.
Borg 280mdc, bad. Borg Head 80mdc. Target that!!

Re: MDC by location combat confusion

Posted: Sun Feb 19, 2017 2:42 am
by Axelmania
What's special about 5 compared to 4 or 6

Re: MDC by location combat confusion

Posted: Sun Feb 19, 2017 1:19 pm
by glitterboy2098
nothing really.

Called shots use up extra attacks per melee (standard called shot is 2, an "aimed called shot" with a strike bonus is 3), and at level 4/5 is when all the HtH skills start gaining extra attacks. however since they all start with enough with 4 actions at level one (aside from assassin, at 3), the gain of a single attack is not a big deal, since at level one you can already get in 2 called shots a melee, or one called shot and some attacks left over for other things.

Re: MDC by location combat confusion

Posted: Sun Feb 19, 2017 6:55 pm
by ShadowLogan
Axelmania wrote:What's special about 5 compared to 4 or 6

As gb2098 suggested it probably is about Attacks per Melee, but that doesn't really make sense as most HTH styles grant their first bonus action by Level 4 (Assassin the exception AFAIK, though some of the Rifts non-main book styles might be different), and getting a bonus .

I'd throw out Weapon Proficiency as another potential candidate or a combination of APM/WP for the strike bonus (with the WP being dependent on the specific weapon proficiency required and the ERA/line it is pulled from). But even this can push the level around and be highly subjective (if one thinks a given bonus value for called shots becomes viable at).

Re: MDC by location combat confusion

Posted: Mon Feb 20, 2017 3:31 am
by drewkitty ~..~
Delrik wrote:What are the combat rules for dealing with opponents with mdc by location? Are called shots used to target these specific areas?

Unless the attacker makes a called shot, the attack hits the main body of the target.
Yes, a called shot is used to attack part of the target that are not it's main body.

Re: MDC by location combat confusion

Posted: Mon Feb 20, 2017 8:44 am
by ShadowLogan
drewkitty ~..~ wrote:
Delrik wrote:What are the combat rules for dealing with opponents with mdc by location? Are called shots used to target these specific areas?

Unless the attacker makes a called shot, the attack hits the main body of the target.
Yes, a called shot is used to attack part of the target that are not it's main body.

True, in addition there is a Historically speaking an Optional rule that used "Random Hit Location Tables".

Robotech (1E) RPG Book 2: RDF Manual pg5 wrote:...I must stress that while these tables can be useful, they are optional. Their inclusion in a game is solely up to each game master.
When to Use the Tables"
The hit location tables can be used to indicate the area of a strike or hit whenever a random (uncalled) shot/attack is made and strikes.


1E Robotech introduced it, but I don't think it was carried over to Rifts or later lines (like 2E). The RHLT available in the 1E books don't even cover every mecha offered up, (IIRC) they are limited to Book2 and Book3 with later generations not getting RHLT, so you have to make you own for each mecha/vehicle type.

EDIT: changed "but" to "in addition" to seem less critical.

Re: MDC by location combat confusion

Posted: Mon Feb 20, 2017 9:00 pm
by drewkitty ~..~
I was stating the basic rules to answer the questions that was asked.

(edit and sent something via PM)

Re: MDC by location combat confusion

Posted: Wed Feb 22, 2017 12:55 am
by Axelmania
drewkitty ~..~ wrote:
Delrik wrote:What are the combat rules for dealing with opponents with mdc by location? Are called shots used to target these specific areas?

Unless the attacker makes a called shot, the attack hits the main body of the target.
Yes, a called shot is used to attack part of the target that are not it's main body.


In the case of this one underwater sled in Underseas you need a called shot to hit the main body too :) At a heavier penalty than some other locations even.

Re: MDC by location combat confusion

Posted: Wed Feb 22, 2017 7:17 pm
by drewkitty ~..~
Axelmania wrote:
drewkitty ~..~ wrote:
Delrik wrote:What are the combat rules for dealing with opponents with mdc by location? Are called shots used to target these specific areas?

Unless the attacker makes a called shot, the attack hits the main body of the target.
Yes, a called shot is used to attack part of the target that are not it's main body.


In the case of this one underwater sled in Underseas you need a called shot to hit the main body too :) At a heavier penalty than some other locations even.

Maybe add a location/page and name?

Re: MDC by location combat confusion

Posted: Thu Feb 23, 2017 10:35 am
by ShadowLogan
drewkitty ~..~ wrote:
Axelmania wrote:
drewkitty ~..~ wrote:
Delrik wrote:What are the combat rules for dealing with opponents with mdc by location? Are called shots used to target these specific areas?

Unless the attacker makes a called shot, the attack hits the main body of the target.
Yes, a called shot is used to attack part of the target that are not it's main body.


In the case of this one underwater sled in Underseas you need a called shot to hit the main body too :) At a heavier penalty than some other locations even.

Maybe add a location/page and name?

Sea "Fin" Combat Sled" WB7 pg103-4 (104 specifically) IINM.

Additionally
There is also an other Historical and Optional Rule found in 1E RT Bk2 pg11 or Bk5 pg 60in the AM-1 Anti-Mecha Mine. Under Damage it notes "Considering this is a land mine, the G.M. may opt to subtract damage from the legs rather than the main body. I personally feel this is the most appropriate; after all the legs are taking the brunt of damage." I've checked the few places I could recall Rifts having Land Mines, but they aren't there.

We probably shouldn't forget that you can attempt to parry an attack to redirect the damage to a location other than the Main Body, but not all attacks can be parried (or done as easily). Missile defense allows one to use the limbs (arms) to block (parry),

Re: MDC by location combat confusion

Posted: Fri Feb 24, 2017 2:53 am
by Axelmania
Aside from the block-sacrifice with the arms are there any other instances of using parries to redirect damage to locations other than the main body?

I don't even think you have to roll a parry to do a missile defense, I don't recall the word parry showing up there. I figured automatic success.

Re: MDC by location combat confusion

Posted: Fri Feb 24, 2017 10:02 am
by ShadowLogan
Axelmania wrote:Aside from the block-sacrifice with the arms are there any other instances of using parries to redirect damage to locations other than the main body?

Melee Combat would be one. Just about every Elite & Basic Robot/PA Combat skill grants a bonus to Parry, and those main book tables tend to be referred back to.

Technically when you use Shields (WP Shield pg 327 RUE) you still take damage. The only thing that doesn't take damage from a parry is another weapon (when both are melee).

Axelmania wrote:I don't even think you have to roll a parry to do a missile defense, I don't recall the word parry showing up there. I figured automatic success.

It doesn't state you roll, but nothing suggests it is an automatic success either. Which is why the groups I've played with have rolled to parry.