RockJock wrote:Higher tech doesn't always mean a more powerful set of armor, or more destructive guns. Better tech can mean it is lighter, easier to use, more versatile, among other things. I think we have different views of Golden Age tech.
I think i have a view that corresponds with the facts in the books. The CS armaments in the RMB are straight-up cutting-edge NEMA technology. The exact same weapons.
I see most of what Triax has done as clawing out of the hole
What hole, precisely?
the NGR never fell. There was no "Dark Age" for Triax In fact, being surrounded by enemies from minute 1, they were under constant pressure to get better and more weapons to the front. (more on this later, but it is covered explicitly several times).
more than expanding scientific and technical knowledge greatly. What Triax and the CS has done, at least from my view is widen the types of units, and things like that, not make stronger materials, or better engines.
Except that Triax is explicitly called out as having done all those things - their armor, when introduced, WAS better than CS armor, etc. They have
Force Fields. Ill cover this more later.
NEMA equipment, for the most part, is designed to be flexible for a paramilitary/police force use.
SomeNEMA equipment is for para-military use. Some is straight up, cutting-edge, golden-age war tech. The Chromium Guardsman was purely military. Same with the Silver Eagle. In fact, the Silver Eagle is explicitly better than the parent military unit (The USA SAMAS, described in Spirit West, which is largely identical to the CS SAM, barring the rail gun, and there's a reason for that) largely because its built out of Chromium Armor.
Most updated CS small arms are in the realm of NEMA gear, but usually a little heavier and/or weaker.
.... what? Im reading Chaos Earth
right now. Remember that at the time, the RMB equipment had been retconned to be burst-capable in some cases. The LSR-250 *is* the the C-12 (misidentified as the C-10). The LGR-360 *is* the C-14 (which for a brief period could fire a 3 round burst for 6D6) though with SDC settings. The PR-470 *is* the C-27. The MX-422 *is* the basis for the Mark V,
only the description even says that the CS version is better.
This holds for EBA,
Which i mentioned.
and PA,
Only because of the Chromium Armor (which i called out as one of the very few exceptions) version of the SAM. The actual USA version didn't use this armor and IS the exact armor the CS uses. From the Golden Age.
but not so well for other equipment, since there are not many examples of from CE. For that you have to branch out to other Golden Age sources, to get apples to apples.
The Super SAM is an extremely powerful suit of power armor, and out classes a Silver Eagle in many ways. The Super Sam has better weapon options in general, and can fly faster, but the Super Sam is also thousands of pounds heavier, has slightly less MDC, and overheats quicker.
The extra weight is almost entirely from the extra weapons it carries, and, yes, the extra
non-Chromium Armor it carries. As i mentioned, the Chromium Armor is one of the ONLY Golden Age technologies that is still "great" - and its even available on Rifts Earth - but i can see why the CS wouldn't use it, because it would make the individual units cost too much. (Which is why FQ's SAM's arent made out of it).
But why talk about the Super SAM (which, honestly, i would NEVER hold up as a shining example of the CS' technology, as quite honestly, the thing is puzzlingly awful)... but rather the Striker SAM (which really should have been the Super SAM). Only weighs 600lbs, carries a huge pile of missiles, is fast and maneuverable, etc.
The only thing that makes the "Silver Eagle" better is the Chromium Armor. That's literally it. And, as i keep pointing out, i said that armor technology was the only place Golden Age tech seems to have kept any kind of edge... sometimes. Their robot vehicles, Power Armor, tanks, and stuff not made out of Chromium Armor kinda blows or is merely on-par with/as good as post-Rifts tech. (And yes, we have plenty of examples - everything the New Navy uses is Golden-Age tech for instance.)
Compare the Bulldog to any CS Robot after the RMB. It's kind of garbage. The Mastiff and Super-Mastiff are... good? Largely because of high MDC (though CS Robots of those sizes have comparable MDC) and high Mini-Missile payloads (and a very good Medium Range missile battery in the Super) But other than that.. they're pretty weaksauce.
Other, non-Chromium PA? The Terror Trooper is better than the Gunbuster is pretty much every conceivable way. The Semper-Fi isn't anything to write home about either.
Another similar example of this is Russia borgs. Both the Shock Troopers and Super Sam are very powerful, but get that via size and brute force not from a higher tech level.
This, however, is explicitly stated as such, and explicitly stated that even in the Golden Age, the Russian tech level wasn't as high, and that was how they compensated. So im not really sure what you're trying to say here.
If the Republic of Japan or Golden Age US decided to build a Borg Shock Trooper, or Super SAMAS with their tech my guess is it would be significantly more powerful then what the Warlords or CS fields.
Your guessing based on... what precisely? The examples of Golden Age tech we do have
do not suggest that their tech level was actually better. The argument you're trying to make is that they could have made so much more better stuff and just didnt. For reasons. That is patently absurd, given that we're told time and again that some of these things were cutting-edge advances and the best things ever produced. This is particularly applicable to Bionics; Mindwerks is pre-Rifts. Their Bionics aren't particularly better than modern ones. There's certainly nothing to suggest that Japan could make some super-duper mega-Cyborg Shock Troopers it just wasn't making for whatever reason and hasn't seen fit to make since they landed on Rifts Earth and have had to fight for their lives (where super-duper mega-Cyborg Shock Troopers would be totes useful).
Heck, a fully loaded GB weighs what a Super Sam weighs without the flight back or railgun.
The Super SAM also weighs more than any other PA in that book (other than the GB killer, which is called a "small robot") by a fair margin for no good reason, so its not exactly the best example. The Striker SAM only weighs 600lbs.
Now I'm thinking of a Hawkeye GB flying around with a really 1.2 ton flight pack....
I'm sure its feasible. There is no reason FQ couldn't do it either, except it wouldn't be as good as just having a dedicated air unit. And the Shadow Boy can fly and hop without all that extra weight.
The Deadman Railgun weighs more then the Striker, but has better reach, all for the same damage and bursts. The CS C-40R is comparable to the NEMA USA-40R, but weighs more and does less damage.
This is specifically addressed in Spirit West; the CS tuned the gun down
on purpose to save ammo. Mentioned in the writeup for the unmodified USA SAM, whose gun is comparable to the NEMA weapon.
The NEMA laser pistol and does more damage then any of the CS laser pistols,
Only for the pulse setting. It does the same damage per shot as the C-20. Range, ill give you... but range is weirdly inconsistent across weapon types and manufacturers, so this isn't a huge category in this argument for me. It IS a factor, but some of them can be chalked up to just sheer dumb.
plus has a better range. The CS Dragon Fire edges out the NEMA Terror Stopper in several categories. In the Terror Stopper's favor, it weighs so much less then the later CS rifle/grenade launcher it is more of a match for the CS CP-40 pulse laser. In that comparison the NEMA gun is lighter, has improved accuracy, similar energy management, plus sdc settings and a grenade launcher. There are plenty of other small arms examples that generally follow this path.
There's really just the one. And you had to compare it to a weapon that it isn't comparable to. We call that moving the goalposts. And the extra accuracy is from (an apparently not-as-good) version of the same scope the C-10 uses. Which you can literally put on anything.
And harping on weight when it is an irrelevant amount of weight isn't really a good argument. If we were talking about the weight making it harder to wield or affecting wether you can even pick it up ("man, this Golden Age man-portable rail gun is only like 20lbs, so anyone can use it!" vs "This C-40R weights like 800lbs and you have to be a borg!") or use it properly, then you'd have a point. But when its an irrelevant amount of weight that doesn't affect the performance of the weapon... /shrug.
I'll freely admit that the CS has a lot more variety of equipment in print, and some examples out class NEMA tech based on that.
When you factor in other Golden Age designs that have been printed in various books, this isn't actually true. There is just as much Golden Age stuff out there as CS stuff for the most part, at least on a per-class basis (as CS War Campaign did add a ton of very derivative PAs and Robots, but we have excellent examples of PA and Robots from the Golden Age in several World Books, as well as the Chaos Earth stuff). There are several PAs (USA SAM, both Bandito SAMs, Semper-Fi PA, various GB models, Japanese SAM), several robots and tanks, absolutely-cutting edge warships (like the Ticonderoga), etc. Several weapons of each type, etc. There's plenty of comparisons.
That's when I start hitting up Golden Age tech in Japan,
Go ahead and name a single thing from the Japan book that is really awesome. (Some Bionics/Cybernetics, i think? But its outright stated that Japan was ahead there anyway, even during the Golden Age.) Don't worry, i'll wait. None of their weapons or PA
Underseas,
Other than the Ticonderoga, nothing in Underseas is particularly impressive. Their tank is "meh", their PA is meh, their main rifle is purely comparable to a number of other pulse weapons in the setting that aren't even new and revolutionary.
Soventski,
Haven't seen that book yet, but the Sovietski stuff in Warlords wasn't anything to write home about. I hear the new book has some bells and whistles, including a game-breakingly bad AP mechanic.
MiO, and both South America books. Things like the JA rifles,
The JA-9 and JA-11 are fine - good and powerful and long range, but not amazingly broken or anything. Other people have lasers that do similar or more damage. The JA-12... there's no defense for it. its an absurdly broken weapon that made no sense when it was introduced and is one of the worst examples of CJ's power creep.
Though how Wilk's never managed to replicate the extended range of the JA-9/11 is beyond me, since its quite clearly stated that their tech was Pre-Rifts and they were the leading laser company in the world. Another one of those editing/continuity things that Palladium is terrible at.
South America GA tech is....
More GBs? Their tanks, infantry weapons (except for that one crazy front-loaded laser rifle/cannon), body armor, and almost all their robots are mediocre or average for their size and the robots at least are all post-Rifts developments.
medical robots,
What exactly are we talking about here? IRMSS stuff? Yes, it was/is Golden Age tech.. but it's still made. Yeah, Rifts Earth hasn't advanced PAST it, but thats not really relevant. That was the best the GA had too. Its not like the GA had little nanobots that could put you back together after you were misted or something.
Chinese PA,
Ill have to dig out my copy of China 2, but i dont recall them being that awesome. And actually, i may not have it since it isnt really my copy. I may have returned it.
and England's Caliber-X are Golden Age remnants, heck, the Phoenix Empire Skimmer tech is assumed to be Golden Age.
I'm not trying to pick a fight, I just think we have different views on what was GA and what is Post Rifts discoveries.
I'm not saying there aren't outliers that are some tech that hasn't been replicated or advanced on by post-Rifts societies. I called out one that stuck out immediately (Armor).
Some fringe stuff like the Skimmer tech in the Phoenix Empire, perhaps (though we have no idea if it is really pre-Rifts or just bought-in or stolen from somewhere). And that's fine - it could very well have been a huge breakthrough in Egypt at the time that then got burried by the Cataclysm. People in NA didn't even have any idea to look for or develop that kind of tech (since they dont exactly have to worry about sand getting everywhere).
But by and large, post-Rifts tech has surpassed or more than equalled GA tech in every way that matters.
Its particularly egregious when it comes to Triax, whose tech should be MILES ahead of anyone else. The NGR never fell. We are told both in WB5 and in Phase World that the reason Rifts Earth tech is so close to 3G tech is because the 3G have reached a stable/natural plateau and that while there are individual conflicts going on, the whole of the 3G haven't been covered in war for millenia or longer, which means military tech is "good enough" for those small wars and individual conflicts and there isn't a ton of advancement going on all the time...
but we're specifically told that Rifts Earth, due to the constant, life-threatening/civilization threating wars, has had incentive to keep up rapid technological progression the entire time,
particularly Triax.
Now, for game purposes, i get why it isn't like that. Just for balance.
But it's a HUGE plot-hole and continuity issue and undermines the entire premise of GA tech being better,
since quite literally everything Triax has is Golden Age + 300 years of rapid advancement.... and is still not really that much better until "just now" (as the stuff in Triax 2 is hillariously powerful in some cases).